Identification of watershed priority management areas based on landscape positions: An implementation using SWAT+
Tong Wu, Liang-Jun Zhu*, Shen Shen, A-Xing Zhu, Mingchang Shi, and Cheng-Zhi Qin
中文版
Overview
Data availablility
Representation
Review history
Submission: 2022-01-19; Manuscript-Submission
Editor assigned: 2022-01-29 (status update requested on 02-22)
Under review: 2022-03-22 (Reviewer(s) invited again on 03-24, and then under review again 03-25)
Reject and resubmit: 2022-04-02; Decision Letter
Comment from Editor: … Both reviewers agree that this topic is interesting and a good fit for the journal. However, both have suggested major revisions …
One of the major concerns of both reviewers was the fact that this new approach was only reviewed for one watershed with results that may or may not represent
a significant improvement; therefore, this weakness should be addressed should you choose to revise and resubmit.
ReSubmission: 2022-09-12; Manuscript-Revision, Revisions and responses
Editor assigned: 2022-09-12 (status update requested on 09-17)
Under review: 2022-09-22 (Reviewer(s) invited again on 09-23, 09-29, 10-07, and 11-04 after status requested and potential reviewers recommended)
Reviews completed: first finished on 10-04, the 2nd finished on 11-14, the 3rd finished on 11-30
With Editor: 2022-11-14 (status updated on 11-30)
Decision in progress: 12-01
Major revision: 2022-12-04; Decision Letter
Comment from Editor: … While all three find the article to be of potential interest to Journal readers and a substantially revised version of the original manuscript,
all three recommend additional major revisions before the manuscript can be considered for publication.
Please carefully review the major suggestions provided by each of the three reviewers which include more clarification of definitions and methods employed and
consideration of the improvement of model efficiency relative to accepted standards.
ReSubmission: 2022-12-25; Manuscript-Revision, Revisions and responses
Editor assigned: 2022-12-26 (status updated on 12-29)
Under review: 2023-01-10
Reviews completed: first finished on 01-15, the 2nd finished on 01-17
With Editor: 2023-01-17
Minor revision: 2023-01-26; Decision Letter
Comment from Editor: I am pleased to say that it has been favourably received and publication with minor revision is recommended. Both previous referees have
reviewed your revised manuscript and found that you thoroughly addressed most of their major concerns. Reviewer
that need to be addressed, however, reviewer
I think you can try to address these remaining concerns through your introduction and discussion sections.
ReSubmission: 2023-01-29; Manuscript-Revision, Revisions and responses
Editor assigned: 2023-01-30 (status updated on 01-31)
Decision in progress: 2023-02-12
Accepted: 2023-02-13; Decision Letter
Citation
Wu, T., Zhu, L.J., Shen, S., Zhu, A.X., Shi, M., and Qin, C.Z. 2023.
Identification of watershed priority management areas based on landscape positions: An implementation using SWAT+.
Journal of Hydrology, 619: 129281.
doi:10.1016/j.jhydrol.2023.129281
« Back
|
